Wikipedia Watchlist vs WikiMonitor

Wikipedia Watchlist vs WikiMonitor

The Watchlist is free, native and the right place to start. It also has four specific limits, all of them documented by Wikipedia and MediaWiki themselves. Here is what it does, where it stops, and when that gap is worth $99 a year.

What the Watchlist does well

It is free, it is built by the people who run the encyclopedia, and it needs no third party. If you are already logged into Wikipedia every day, it will show you every change to every page you follow, in one list, with full diffs a click away.

For an active editor, that is the correct tool and nothing here should talk you out of it.

Where it stops

1. The email arrives once

MediaWiki's own manual states that after a notification is sent you have to visit the page while logged in before another one will be sent. If you do not, the alerts stop, and nothing tells you they have stopped. For someone who is not a daily editor, this is the difference between being watched and believing you are watched.

MediaWiki, Manual:$wgEnotifWatchlist

2. Notifications cannot be scoped to one page

Wikipedia's help documentation says email notification cannot be limited by page. Follow anything else and those changes arrive in the same inbox, so the one article you actually care about competes with everything else you have ever watched.

Wikipedia, Help:Watchlist

3. The email does not contain the change

It tells you the page was edited and links you to it. Working out what happened means opening the history and comparing revisions yourself. At 5 AM on a phone, that is the step where most people decide to look at it later.

4. It requires an account and setup

A registered, logged-in Wikipedia account, with notification settings spread across two preference tabs. Not difficult, but it is a Wikipedia account created solely to watch yourself, which many subjects would rather not have.

Side by side

 Wikipedia WatchlistWikiMonitor
PriceFree$99 a year, one page
Wikipedia accountRequiredNot required
Alert on every editFirst edit, then it stopsEvery edit
Change includedNo, link onlyYes, in the email
Scoped to one pageNoYes
Editor identifiedIn the historyIn the email
SpeedNo stated targetWithin 60 seconds

Which one you want

Use the Watchlist

You edit Wikipedia regularly, you are logged in most days, and checking a list is already part of your routine. It is free and it is enough.

Pay for monitoring

The article is about you or your company, you are not going to log into Wikipedia every day, and finding out late would cost you something. The gap the Watchlist leaves is exactly the case where it matters.

Start monitoring now.

Tell us the page and where alerts should go. We confirm the article is the right one and take you straight to checkout.

Payment is handled by Stripe. Nothing on this page touches your card details. Need more pages than the Agency tier, or invoicing? Talk to us.